Old-Fashioned Cafeteria

Rediscovering Sweet Simplicity: Crafting the Perfect Old-Fashioned Cafeteria Peanut Butter Candy

Embark on a journey down memory lane as we explore the timeless allure of Old-Fashioned Cafeteria Peanut Butter Candy. This classic treat, reminiscent of simpler times, carries the nostalgia of school cafeterias and grandmas’ kitchens. Join me in unlocking the secrets to recreate this cherished delicacy, where the unmistakable blend of peanut butter and sweetness takes center stage, providing a taste of comfort and tradition in every bite.


For the Peanut Butter Candy:

  • 2 cups granulated sugar
  • 1/2 cup whole milk
  • 1 cup creamy peanut butter
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • Pinch of salt

For the Peanut Butter Frosting:

  • 1/2 cup unsalted butter, softened
  • 1 cup creamy peanut butter
  • 2 cups powdered sugar
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 2-3 tablespoons whole milk (as needed)


1. Prepare the Peanut Butter Candy Base:

  • In a medium-sized saucepan over medium heat, combine granulated sugar and whole milk.
  • Stir continuously until the mixture comes to a boil.
  • Allow it to boil for 2-3 minutes without stirring.

2. Incorporate Peanut Butter:

  • Remove the saucepan from heat and stir in creamy peanut butter, vanilla extract, and a pinch of salt until well combined.

3. Set and Cut:

  • Pour the peanut butter candy mixture into a parchment paper-lined square baking dish.
  • Allow it to cool and set for at least 2 hours or until firm.
  • Once set, cut the candy into squares.

4. Make the Peanut Butter Frosting:

  • In a mixing bowl, beat softened butter and creamy peanut butter until smooth and creamy.
  • Gradually add powdered sugar and vanilla extract, continuing to beat until well incorporated.
  • Adjust the consistency with whole milk, adding 1 tablespoon at a time until the frosting reaches your desired spreadable texture.

5. Frost and Enjoy:

  • Spread the peanut butter frosting over the cut peanut butter candy squares.
  • Allow the frosting to set for an additional 30 minutes before serving.

Cooking Notes:

  • Use high-quality creamy peanut butter for a smoother texture.
  • Adjust the amount of powdered sugar in the frosting to suit your sweetness preference.
  • To speed up the setting process, place the peanut butter candy in the refrigerator.


Chocolate Drizzle Delight:

  • Melt semi-sweet chocolate chips and drizzle over the peanut butter frosting for a decadent touch.
  • Sprinkle chopped peanuts on top before the chocolate sets for added crunch.

Coconut Crunch Sensation:

  • Mix shredded coconut into the peanut butter candy base for a tropical twist.
  • Top the frosting with additional coconut flakes for a delightful crunch.

Caramel Swirl Symphony:

  • Swirl caramel sauce into the peanut butter candy before it sets for a gooey, caramelized flavor.
  • Drizzle extra caramel over the frosting for an indulgent finish.

Keto Version:

For those committed to a keto lifestyle, the Old-Fashioned Cafeteria Peanut Butter Candy can be adapted to fit your dietary preferences.

  • Replace granulated sugar with a keto-friendly sweetener like erythritol or stevia.
  • Use unsweetened almond milk instead of whole milk.
  • Adjust the amount of peanut butter to fit your macronutrient goals.

Low-Carb Version:

If you’re watching your carb intake, here’s how to modify the Old-Fashioned Cafeteria Peanut Butter Candy while preserving its delightful essence.

  • Opt for a low-carb sweetener in both the candy base and the frosting.
  • Choose a low-carb milk substitute for the candy base.
  • Reduce the amount of peanut butter in both the candy and the frosting to minimize carb content.

A Taste of Nostalgia in Every Bite:

As we wrap up our journey through the recipe for Old-Fashioned Cafeteria Peanut Butter Candy, relish in the joy of recreating a cherished treat from the past. These simple yet delightful squares encapsulate the essence of comforting flavors and sweet memories.

Whether shared with loved ones or savored in a quiet moment of reflection, Old-Fashioned Cafeteria Peanut Butter Candy invites you to celebrate the sweetness of tradition. So, gather your ingredients, set the stage for a trip down memory lane, and let the aroma of peanut butter and nostalgia fill your kitchen. Here’s to the enduring magic of simple pleasures and the timeless joy found in every nostalgic bite!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Grandma’s Polish Cookies

Homestyle Slow Cooker Pork Chops